Cucara Macara is located on 32nd street just north of Oak, in Phoenix and has been around for a couple months. The interior is was nice and welcoming with a cute little sign with the shops name, over the case holding the ice cream. The shop features a couple basic ice cream flavors, but in an effort to be adventurous I tried out some of their more unique offerings. A decent amount of reviews for Cucara Macara say that the cheese, and pine nut ice cream were delightful, but I was craving something sweeter. While looking through the reviews, I had also read that some people described the ice cream as being more ice then cream. The person behind the counter must have heard this complaint before, because before I tasted my first sample, they let me know that because the ice cream was homemade, it would have a texture that I might not be accustomed to.
After tasting my way through the ice cream case, I settled on Soursop (Graviola) and Mammee Fruit. Both flavors had a very subtle sweetness and tasted like a combination of guava and vanilla. While the flavor was nice, the texture of the ice cream didn’t have much body and the combo left me feeling thoroughly whelmed.
While I have never made ice cream myself, I have eaten ice cream all across the world (several US states, plus Canada and Japan). With my ice cream credentials laid out on the table, I will make the bold claim that Cucara Macara’s ice cream texture issue isn’t from being homemade. If I had to take a guess (not an expert), I would say that they’re not using enough butterfat, or they scaled up homemade recipes that require some extra work to prevent from icing up. I don’t say this because I think I could do better, I say this because it’s a crutch to blame the disappointing texture on the ice cream being “homemade”. Many other local ice cream shops make their own ice cream daily, and don’t have this issue.
Cucara Macara is a local and family owned ice cream shop, in a city filled with ice cream shops. Currently they have pretty of glowing reviews on Yelp and Google. As time goes on, there is a good chance that if they don’t change their ice cream recipe, other picky reviewers will express similar concerns. I really want them to succeed, because the ice cream world could use more fun flavors. Currently, I would only recommend visiting them if you want to see what cheese ice cream would taste like, or you live nearby.